Archive for June, 2007

While 15 Sioux Empire Astronomy Club (SEAC) members & friends were having a grand time together at the last New Moon Saturday gathering on June 16 (CDT), early that evening the big Obsession telescope ran into trouble. It was caught by the opening roof and its upper stage was nearly separated from the supporting poles. Very fortunately Jim Morris and John Johnson (“JJ” for short) came running to help Dick Hodgson with the problem. It took a few anxious minutes to reconnect the upper stage and poles, requiring the telescope be put in vertical position. Fortunately JJ is very tall and has a
big reach, and was able to make the adjustments at the top of a ladder, assisted by Jim and Dick below. The upper stage was reconnected better than it had been in years.

But having done this rescue of the valuable telescope, the challenge was not over. There were two immediate consequences of this accident: (1) the optical alignment of the big telescope had to be reestablished, using a special

Cheshire eyepiece and also a LaserMate laser collimator. Temporary optical alignment was achieved for use Saturday evening, but we realized performance would only be so-so for the evening. We discovered the secondary mirror at the top end of the telescope still was not seeing quite the entire main mirror, so the scope was less than fully efficient. This problem has probably been present for some time.

The second consequence of the accident (2) was that the very good Argo Navis alignment made last January was invalidated. Thus we needed to re-align the Argo Navis computer with the realities of the night sky. We had problems getting a good fix on our second alignment star (Altair) — the hazy sky conditions in the

Aquila area of the sky at the time added to the problem. After a poor star alignment was achieved we did manage to offer views of the Dumbbell Nebula in Vulpecula (M27) to the New Moon gathering, but after that initial limited success, our Argo Navis failed to find other objects. Socially that night was a great success, and other telescopes functioned well and gave folks delightful views, but that night we knew the big Obsession needed more work!  (This is written to remind us all that even big telescopes can have a bad night, and that we can all learn from an analysis of their problems, so listen up.)

On Monday evening, June 18 (CDT) JJ returned to Hodgson Observatory late afternoon to fix the big Obsession. (He brought his own Obsession along but never unloaded it.)  The trees at Sunniside largely sheltered the Observatory from the strong NW winds of the evening, and the skies were largely clear most of the evening and night. The telescope’s optical alignment was the focus of attention. It was immediately clear from an examination with the

Cheshire eyepiece that the secondary mirror was misaligned. The secondary mirror was loose in its housing, rattling a bit. This problem was solved with stuffing polyester “cotton” batten behind the mirror until it was tight.

The secondary mirror also needed to be on a longer 3/8th inch bolt than its original. We had no spare longer bolts in inventory, so we pulled one over-long carriage bolt out of a Observatory roof track support (substituting a shorter bolt pro tempore), hacksawed its end off, and attached the secondary mirror to it. Then the secondary mirror was repositioned, and carefully checked with the LaserMate laser, then tightened down, rechecked, readjusted, retightened, rechecked, readjusted, retightened, etc. JJ is a perfectionist when it comes to optics – one of the best in

America when it comes to optical alignments.

Then we went on to the primary mirror, guided by the LaserMate device. The primary mirror was rehung in its supporting strap for better support. Then it was adjusted inward until all of the big mirror was reflected in the secondary mirror and was being received by the eyepiece. The track of the laser beam through the optical system then hit the tiny cross in the exact center of the big mirror. Then everything was tightened down, rechecked, adjusted until perfect, then tightened down, rechecked, etc. You know the
litany. It goes on until the rechecking with the laser shows the last tightening has done no harm whatever to the alignment.

It was then sundown. We thrilled we had gotten the optical realignment achieved, and achieved before dark. The view in the big telescope had never been as good.

We paused for coffee and brownies at the house as night fell. Then back at the telescope we did the necessary star alignment for the Argo Navis/ServoCAT system. We used Polaris and Spica in the southwestern sky as alignment stars, centering them initially in the field at 84x, increasing power to 201x, and re-centering, then sending the location by wireless to the Argo Navis. Almost magically, at the same time, JJ managed to achieve
the best optical alignments ever of the 120mm f/8.3 refractor which rides on top of the Obsession, and of its 8x50mm finder scope with that of the big telescope. We were both thrilled.

This resulting star alignment for the Argo Navis initially was an only fair-to-good one. That was not good enough. We wondered if we would have to go back to square one an repeat the job. Then JJ did something not mentioned in the literature that was brilliant. While the Obsession was tracking the sky, he suggested we do an extra star alignment, this time using Altair in the eastern sky. I centered Altair in the center of the field at 201x and called out to JJ who immediately hit “enter” at the console. (We found that using the wireless in this case with the telescope already running did not work, but with a second person at the console, it could and did work.)  In effect what we had done was to substitute in Argo Navis’ mind the Altair data for that of Polaris which lacked the precision we needed.   ALL ARGO NAVIS / ServoCAT SYSTEM OWNERS SHOULD BE AWARE OF THIS TRICK!

By (and a second round of coffee at the house) we were ready to do some testing on several objects to see how well the Argo Navis system was aligned. We ran several objects, using a fairly narrow field

Brandon 16mm orthoscopic eyepiece (yielding 201x), and finding we had a pointing accuracy of about ~ 0.2 of a degree. Wow!!  We might have gone on all night, but clouds moved in so we closed off our observing at   (Note: On the night following (2007 June 19/20 JJ and I observed again) with the Argo Navis finding all targets with ~ 0.3 degree accuracy. But the details of that night are another exciting story!)    –  Dick Hodgson

Subject: Grand Time at SEAC New Moon Saturday NightFrom the many delighted comments we had from the 15 people who were able to attend the SEAC New Moon Saturday night gathering, a grand time was had by all!  As predicted most of the clouds and all of the threatening weather passed away from our rural Hodgson Observatory site by early evening, and we had a good night of until about 12:30 a.m. CDT when the sky began to be covered with thin diffuse cloud. There was a lot of useful discussion on astronomy and equipment, and help given generously to help those with instrument problems. A few of us hung on until after 2 a.m., seeing bright targets (like Jupiter) through thin clouds.  Thanks to all who helped to make it a delightful time!

Just for your information, the next SEAC New Moon Saturday gathering will be held at Hodgson Observatory in rural Beresford, SD, on July 14.  In August it will be held in the same place on August 11. Mark your calendars and plan to join us if you can. More details on these events will be sent later.

Remember also that the 2007 South Dakota Star Party will be held on the Hodgson Observatory grounds from Friday, September 7 to Sunday morning, September 9.  Keep checking the SEAC website for more information as the annual SD Starry Party draws closer!

Wishing us all clear skies, Dick Hodgson

WHAT A NIGHT 2007 JUNE 19/20 WAS AT HODGSON OBSERVATORY!

Last night was one of the best. Cloudless, almost windless, low humidity, temperatures declining slowly into the upper 50′s F. Seeing was very good although we were not focused on very high magnification work. Totally gone was the haziness of the past week. At a joint examination of the bowl of the Little Dipper (Ursa Minor) showed stars clearly down to ~ +6.5 magnitude against a black sky.

John Johnson (“JJ”) joined me about and set up his 508mm (20-inch) Obsession ENE of  Hodgson Observatory. Then he installed the Student version of “The Sky” astronomy software in the Observatory computer (the one located in the alcove (i.e., “The Cave”).  Then the Sun set.

After a brief coffee break at the house, we commenced operations about 45 minutes after sunset. The Argo Navis / ServoCAT alignment secured last night proved to be very good, well within the mark using the 38mm 84.6x primary eyepiece.  (See a separate e-mail called “635mm (25-inch) Obsession Telescope Repair & Upgrade” for the story). Here we recount briefly highlights of this exceptionally fine night for observing.

JJ looked at a considerable number of Messier and New General Catalogue (NGC) objects. He tended to look often at objects fairly close to zenith. After initial set-up, JJ’s telescope showed a magnificent view of the Great Globular Cluster in Hercules, M13, the finest globular star cluster in the northern hemisphere, containing about 500,000 stars. This was followed by a fine view of M27, the Dumbbell Nebula in Vulpecular, an expanding nebula resulting from a stellar explosion in its central star a few thousand years ago.

A highlight of the evening for both of us was Jupiter. Three satellites were visible initially, but a fourth emerged from behind the planet in the late evening. Using a 42mm eyepiece borrowed from JJ (yielding 78x) and comparing it with my own 38mm eyepiece (84.6x), Jupiter at low power was very impressive in the 635mm (25-inch) Obsession. Atmospheric belt details were exquisite in both eyepieces. Wow!!  The satellites were seen as beautiful round spheres, with no effects of coma or optical distortion, probably the result of very good seeing conditions, atmospheric clarity here in South Dakota, and the new optical alignment of the telescope recently achieved. At 201x (

Brandon Orthoscopic 16mm eyepiece) Jupiter was still well seen in its details, but almost “over-bright” to the eye. A pale blue wratten filter # 81A was also used with the Brandon Orthoscopic to intensify the details of the darker belts in Jupiter’s atmosphere, judged to be a slight improvement given last night’s conditions. Nearly an hour was spent on Jupiter.

The other highlight of the evening for both of us was the sight of the TWO brightest component super-galaxies in the Great Hercules Galaxy Supercluster of tens of thousands of galaxies, NGC 6166 — the brightest of all – and NGC 6160, both well seen in JJ’s telescope at 120x in spite of the waxing crescent Moon. Both of them are ~ 430,000,000 light years distant (based on a 71 km/sec/ Megaparsec value for the Hubble constant). That takes us back to the end of the Ordovician Period in Earth’s geologic history, a time
shortly before life began to live on land and breathe Earth’s atmosphere! Wow!   (I had seen NGC 6166 previously as mentioned in an earlier note, but never NGC 6160. JJ had seen neither previously.)

Other objects of interest seen with the 635mm (24-inch) Obsession were globular star clusters: impressive M80 in Scorpius;  the small, loose globular M71 in Sagitta; moderately remote globular NGC 6934 in Delphinus, and the very remote NGC 7006 (~ 175,000 light years away), also in Delphinus. Also well seen was the Dumbbell Nebula (M27) in Vulpecula.  JJ had an excellent view of M5, the famous Whirlpool Galaxy,  which permitted us to trace its spiral arms in detail, and see details of its companion
galaxy NGC 5195. We observed until about     –  Dick Hodgson